Dry Flies can be a Problem: Dry flies are a super part of our sport. Not one can deny that. But if you love dry flies too much, dry flies can be a problem.
I was on the river early this morning, working a team of nymphs through some promising water. Things were slow. Which was a bit surprising given the day before this spot had been red hot. But we all have experienced that stuff. Different days often supply different fishing.
Downstream from me a guy was working a dry fly. Awhile later he strolled off to explore new waters. I fished on. After an hour, he reappeared and struck up a conversation. It went like this.
“Anything doing,” he inquired?
“Got one,” I replied.
“Been here six times this season already and have yet to catch a single fish!” he exclaimed with disgust.
“Did Okay here yesterday,” I added. “There’s fish here believe me.”
“Catch’em on nymphs,” he asked?
“Yeah, its the best method on this river.”
“I don’t fish nymphs,” he shot back. “a fish on a dry is more fun that a fish on a nymph. Don’t you agree?”
“Yeah…but a fish on nymph is more fun than no fish on a dry,” I answered.
“Maybe,” he said looking off.
Then asked me if I fished here often. I said no, adding I was just up from Florida for the summer. Next he wanted to know if I fly-fished the salt in Florida. Yes, I told him, inquiring if he fished in the salt too. His answer was no. I kind of figured that, but dug deeper.
“Why not,” I asked?
“Those saltwater flies aren’t really flies….their lures,” he informed me.
“Your Adams dry is a lure too, ” I told him.
At that he shrugged his shoulders and slowly walked off to his car. I guess I hadn’t made my point. Man oh man, dry flies can be a problem. Amigo, the bitter war between Halford and Skues lives on even today.
Opinions are only a problem when we bore ass others with them. Remember when fly tiers who used epoxy were considered pariahs? I guess fly fishing has its own Taliban. Let’s hope they don’t organize and have sweeps on rivers to purge and punish impure fly fishers.
Ted Rzepski
Amen,Ted. Some anglers get very closed minded. Its as bad as politics, for Pete’s sake. I knew a fly tyer that steadfastly refused to use any synthetic materials; everything had to be 100 % natural. Only fur and feathers were permissible. No tinsel, no flashabou, no copper wire, nothing man-made allowed. Yet the biggest part of all his flies was a metal hook!